Why Grammar Schools Should Stay in the Past

A response to The Saint’s article, ‘Bring Back Grammar Schools’

Last week The Saint published an article entitled ‘Bring Back Grammar Schools’, leaving me compelled to discuss my reasons for believing this is a bad idea.

For any non-Brits who may not be entirely familiar with our education system, a grammar school is a form of selective school, which requires you to pass an exam to get in, with state funding. In the 1960s, the British government made a move to abolish these grammar schools, coinciding with the introduction of comprehensive secondary schools which accept everybody. Most existing grammar schools at this point either became private schools, or merged with existing non-selective schools. Some areas of the UK, however, for reasons unbeknownst to me, were able to retain their grammar schools, and I grew up in one of these areas.

Photo: Wikipedia

I attended a standard comprehensive until I was 16, before switching to a grammar school for A Levels. Though I massively enjoyed my time at a grammar school, it really opened my eyes to a number of issues, and I now firmly believe they should remain as non-existent as possible.

Archie Batra of The Saint writes that grammar schools were “designed to be great engines of social mobility.” Whilst this was certainly true when they were first introduced, this is sadly no longer the case. Grammar schools have instead become vessels for wealthy parents to ensure their children gain a first-class education, without having to fork out private school fees. Children arriving at grammar schools in Year 7 invariably all already know each other because they attended the same private tutoring service in preparation for the entrance exams.

My boyfriend tells a story of a Year 7 parents welcome evening at our grammar school where parents were, in as many words, asked to donate large sums of money to the school, which they all had in abundance as they were getting away without paying private school fees. There is a certain expectation of wealthy families even amongst the teachers and leadership teams at most grammar schools in the UK. To be frank, the elitism of St Andrews came as no shock to me, because I had already experienced it all at school; I was definitely one of the worse-off students in my year, despite coming from a distinctly middle-class background.

Photo: Flickr

Furthermore, the environment at grammar schools can be incredibly toxic due to a lack of diversity, with large numbers of highly gifted children all competing to be the best. I have never experienced the sort of pressure to achieve as I did whilst at a grammar school, and it was reflected in the mental health of myself and my classmates. Off the top of my head I can think of 3 girls in my year alone who publicly had to spend significant amounts of time in hospital due to eating disorders. This, compared to no one in my class at a comprehensive school publicly suffering from such things speaks volumes about the sort of environment cultivated at grammar schools.

On a different note, grammar schools can be wonderful centres for learning; they have wonderful resources, and attract all of the best teachers. So where does that leave the less “intelligent” children who have to attend comprehensives? Should they not also be given the opportunity to have a decent education? Instead, they get left with often sub-par teachers, despite being the students who would arguably benefit the most from good teaching.

I concede that the concept of grammar schools is alluring. In a perfect world they make a lot of sense, and I do value my time at one. However, in the interest of creating a sustainably inclusive society and education system, they need to remain in the past, and the government needs to work on improving comprehensives so that everyone can access good education, not just the lucky few.

Comments

comments

8 thoughts on “Why Grammar Schools Should Stay in the Past

  1. Jeetwin Affiliate

    Jeetwin Affiliate
    Join Jeetwin now! | Jeetwin sign up for a ?500 free bonus
    Spin & fish with Jeetwin club! | 200% welcome bonus
    Bet on horse racing, get a 50% bonus! | Deposit at Jeetwin live for rewards
    #JeetwinAffiliate
    Casino table fun at Jeetwin casino login | 50% deposit bonus on table games
    Earn Jeetwin points and credits, enhance your play!
    https://www.jeetwin-affiliate.com/hi

    #JeetwinAffiliate #jeetwinclub #jeetwinsignup #jeetwinresult
    #jeetwinlive #jeetwinbangladesh #jeetwincasinologin
    Daily recharge bonuses at Jeetwin Bangladesh!
    25% recharge bonus on casino games at jeetwin result
    15% bonus on Crash Games with Jeetwin affiliate!

    Turn to Earn Authentic Funds and Gift Vouchers with JeetWin’s Partner Program

    Do you a supporter of web-based gaming? Do you actually appreciate the excitement of turning the reel and succeeding big? If so, subsequently the JeetWin Affiliate Program is great for you! With JeetWin Casino, you not simply get to experience enthralling games but additionally have the chance to make authentic funds and gift vouchers just by publicizing the platform to your friends, family, or virtual audience.

    How Does Work?

    Signing up for the JeetWin’s Referral Program is speedy and effortless. Once you turn into an associate, you’ll acquire a unique referral link that you can share with others. Every time someone joins or makes a deposit using your referral link, you’ll receive a commission for their activity.

    Amazing Bonuses Await!

    As a member of JeetWin’s affiliate program, you’ll have access to a selection of appealing bonuses:

    Sign Up Bonus 500: Receive a bountiful sign-up bonus of INR 500 just for joining the program.

    Welcome Deposit Bonus: Take advantage of a whopping 200% bonus when you fund and play fruit machine and fish games on the platform.

    Infinite Referral Bonus: Acquire unlimited INR 200 bonuses and rebates for every friend you invite to play on JeetWin.

    Thrilling Games to Play

    JeetWin offers a broad range of the most played and most popular games, including Baccarat, Dice, Liveshow, Slot, Fishing, and Sabong. Whether you’re a fan of classic casino games or prefer something more modern and interactive, JeetWin has something for everyone.

    Join the Best Gaming Experience

    With JeetWin Live, you can enhance your gaming experience to the next level. Take part in thrilling live games such as Lightning Roulette, Lightning Dice, Crazytime, and more. Sign up today and embark on an unforgettable gaming adventure filled with excitement and limitless opportunities to win.

    Simple Payment Methods

    Depositing funds and withdrawing your winnings on JeetWin is fast and hassle-free. Choose from a variety of payment methods, including E-Wallets, Net Banking, AstroPay, and RupeeO, for seamless transactions.

    Don’t Overlook on Special Promotions

    As a JeetWin affiliate, you’ll gain access to exclusive promotions and special offers designed to maximize your earnings. From cash rebates to lucrative bonuses, there’s always something exciting happening at JeetWin.

    Install the Mobile Application

    Take the fun with you wherever you go by downloading the JeetWin Mobile Casino App. Available for both iOS and Android devices, the app features a wide range of entertaining games that you can enjoy anytime, anywhere.

    Enroll in the JeetWin’s Affiliate Scheme Today!

    Don’t wait any longer to start earning real cash and exciting rewards with the JeetWin Affiliate Program. Sign up now and join the thriving online gaming community at JeetWin.

  2. PBN sites
    We establish a system of self-owned blog network sites!

    Merits of our PBN network:

    We carry out everything SO THAT google does not grasp THAT this is A privately-owned blog network!!!

    1- We obtain domains from separate registrars

    2- The leading site is hosted on a VPS server (Virtual Private Server is rapid hosting)

    3- The remaining sites are on various hostings

    4- We allocate a unique Google account to each site with confirmation in Search Console.

    5- We create websites on WP, we do not utilize plugins with assistance from which malware penetrate and through which pages on your websites are generated.

    6- We refrain from duplicate templates and use only individual text and pictures

    We do not work with website design; the client, if desired, can then edit the websites to suit his wishes

  3. Good day! I know this is somewhat off topic but I
    was wondering which blog platform are you using for this website?
    I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at options for another platform.
    I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a
    good platform.

  4. As Mike Johnson tries to pass billions of dollars in aid to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan, he’s having to put his own job on the line
    blacksprut
    Johnson moving ahead with Ukraine aid bill despite pressure from hardliners
    US Senate kills articles of impeachment against Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas
    Ex-Trump attorney asked if he thinks Trump should testify. Hear reply 1:29
    https://bs-gl.org
    Analysis Some House Republicans need this reminder that Russia is not their friend
    Viewers called in with Trump trial questions. Maggie Haberman answered 1:50
    If Trump testifies at NY criminal trial, prosecutors want to use his past legal run-ins to discredit him to jury
    Fact check: Donald Trump attacks Jimmy Kimmel for something Al Pacino did
    blacksprut
    https://bs-gl.org

  5. Thanks for the marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you will be a
    great author. I will make certain to bookmark your
    blog and may come back someday. I want to encourage
    you to definitely continue your great work, have
    a nice weekend!

  6. When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox
    and now each time a comment is added I get three emails with the same comment.

    Is there any way you can remove me from that service?

    Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

THE STAND