HMS Pinafore – Theatre Review

Deputy Events Editor Jade Mkparu reviews the St Andrews Gilbert and Sullivan Society’s production of HMS Pinafore.

Green and blue light pools on the velvet curtain. It soon lifts, revealing a boat, the sea and the sky. In the pit below, the orchestra begins to begin to set the scene. Then sailors march on stage, putting words to the melody; with all these elements in motion, the story begins…


I thoroughly enjoyed watching the premiere show of HMS Pinafore by the Gilbert and Sullivan Society. As a newcomer to the opera scene, I was struck by the way in which a sense of the heightened, a sense of sheer dexterity but also effortless synergy seemed to underpin the performances on stage, behind the scenes and in the orchestra pit. Right from the opening, it was the coming together of these various elements and efforts that really pulled the audience in and invited me to wade into the world of HMS Pinafore.


Co-produced by Louise Stevenson and Louise Anderbjork, this production of Gilbert and Sullivan’s comic opera synergised the design, acting and musical elements in such a way that the storytelling felt holistic and truly multi-sensory. In the absence of actors, I would still be able to get a sense of the mood and the tone of different moments from the instrumentals. This opera’s tale is one of love and status, and how these two concepts can shape our outlook on society as well as our ideas of self. The tension between the two was the conundrum that troubled the star-crossed couple Maeve Mackstraw (Catriona Kadirkamanathan) and Josephine (Amy Dunn), which Kadirkamanathan hauntingly lamented in her first solo ‘The Nightingale Sighed’.


Source: St Andrews Gilbert and Sullivan Society, Louise Anderbjork (Atlas Camera)


From the humorous exchanges between Dylan Swain’s Captain Corcoran and Georgie Duncan’s Buttercup, to the impressive swell of the full company and orchestra’s harmonies, Co-Music Directors Alasdair Richmond and Kylie Lam did a great job at conducting the musical numbers. For each of the principal actors, their solos brought out the best in their voices, impressing the audience with the richness, depth and heights they could achieve. One of my favourite scenes was the opening of the second act: as the curtains withdrew to reveal a moonlit backdrop with dozens of twinkling lights, the audience audibly gasped at beautiful simplicity of the set design. Dunn’s solo a few scenes later reached stellar heights, with the expressionistic red and blue spotlights on either side of her symbolising a nice symbolic touch by the lighting crew (led by Technical Director Robert Moran) and Artistic Director Peter Black. Costumier Julia Lisco’s choice of pieces also emphasised the contrast between the uniformity of the sailors and the opulence of the ladies and men of higher rank, again highlighting the impasse between the classes. Lisco also made colourful statements, with details such as the glittering brocade on the sleeves of Rt. Honourable Sir Joseph KCB (played by James Forshaw) or the plain, shimmering white of Josephine’s gown connoting either the pompous or understated natures of their characters.


Source: St Andrews Gilbert and Sullivan Society, Louise Anderbjork (Atlas Camera)


There are moments of intrigue, suspense and shock; you root for the ensemble as they steal across the deck to the secret wedding, and hope that the attempts to thwart it by Dick Deadeye (Alex Dingley) do not succeed. Overall, HMS Pinafore is an opera with a timeless message about the folly of trying to box people into convenient roles: it shows, rather, how arbitrary things like social status are, and (by contrast) how and invaluable love and good character can be. With such a precedence set, I am certainly looking forward to G&S’ production of Princess Ida next semester, and a return to the topsy-turvy, wonderful world of Gilbert and Sullivan.



771 thoughts on “HMS Pinafore – Theatre Review

  1. Definitely believe that which you stated. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I definitely get irked while people think about worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  2. Pingback: stockholm jobs
  3. Pingback: warsaw jobs
  4. Thanx for the effort, keep up the good work Great work, I am going to start a small Blog Engine course work using your site I hope you enjoy blogging with the popular you express are really awesome. Hope you will right some more posts.

  5. order propecia without rx order generic propecia or propecia cost cost of propecia tablets
    buying propecia price cost of generic propecia without prescription and home order cheap propecia without a prescription

  6. Onlayn bahis platformalar? ?ld? etmek gordum a tokm?k icind? t?qdis etm?k dunyada, qurban verm?k istifad?cil?r? istirak rahatl?g? bir s?ra evl?rind?n v? ya yoldan qumar oyunlar?n?n formalar?. Bu platformalar ad?t?n tender bir ensiklopedik menzil Idman bahisl?ri, kazino oyunlar? v? daha cox da daxil olmaqla seciml?r. Buna gor? Qumar?n oldugu Az?rbaycandak? istifad?cil?r g?rgin T?nziml?n?n, onlayn platformalar c?xarmaq bir prospekt doyus olmaya bil?c?k f?aliyy?tl?rd? r?van indiki boyunca ?n?n?vi varl?q.

    Az?rbaycanda qumar oyunu birind? movcuddur huquqi bozluq. Is? mu?yy?n T?yin olunmus ?razil?rd? qumar oyunlar?n?n formalar? icaz? verilir, onlayn qumar kommutator qaydalar? il? uzl?sir. Bu hokum?t var ovsunlu olcul?ri conun?n D?niz bahis veb saytlar?na giris, ancaq saylanmayan Az?rbaycanl?lar h?tta qorxutmaq ucun ?ngin platformalar d?st?kl? qumar ehtiyaclar?. Bu a yarad?r t?klif etm?k ucun Az?rbaycan bazar?na uygun onlayn bahis xidm?tl?ri.

    1WIN AZ?RBAYCAN A olsayd? lisenziya Onlayn bahis siyas?t Az?rbaycanl? istifad?cil?r? yem?k ist?rdimi ehtimal ki tender bir heterogenlik Xususiyy?tl?r v? t?klifl?r oxsar dig?rin? beyn?lmil?l platformalar. Bunlar ola bil?r daxil etm?k Idman bahisin? adi Dunyadak? hadis?l?r, a secm? yuvalardan tutmus kazino oyunlar?ndan yuklu dukanc? t?crub? v? bonuslar v? promosyonlar aldatmaq v? qorumaq must?ril?r?.

    Motorlu Uygunluq olard? imperativ t?msilcilik istifad?cil?r? yem?k t?r?find? ucun bahis etm?k ustund? getm?k, il? s?hn?l?sdirm?k ?ski mobil dostluq veb sayt v? ya xususi bir t?tbiq. Od?nis seciml?ri d? olard? f?rql?n?n, yerlik bir nec? ustunlukl?r v? t?min edir Bagl? ?m?liyyatlar. ?lav? olaraq, q?rp?nmaq oglan ?zm?k oynamaq bir kritik x?td? Unvanda istehlakc? sorgular v? t?min etm?k fayda verm?k N? laz?m olduqda.

    Onlayn bahis platformalar? olmaq rahatl?q v? yay?nma, Budur l?yaq?tli o vaxtdan b?ri istifad?cil?r m?sq etm?k cubuq v? qumar oynamaq m?suliyy?tl?. Huslu kimi qumar t?dbirl?ri bank M?hdudiyy?tl?r v? ozunu istisna seciml?ri, olmal?d?r at ucun mualic? istifad?cil?r etm?k onlar?n bahis f?aliyy?ti v? k?narlasmaq potensial z?r?r verm?k. Yan t?min etm?k a z?h?rli olmayan v? xos bahis muhit, "1" kimi platformalarBirinci yer? nail olmaq Az?rbaycan "ed? bil?rdi ?rzaq adland?rark?n az?rbaycanl? istifad?cil?rin ehtiyaclar?na muvafiq Qaydalar v? t?blig nufuzlu qumar t?crub?l?ri.

  7. Southwestern – see Wildtree (other Southwestern sub-brands include Southwestern Advantage*, Southwestern Consulting, Southwestern Real Estate, Southwestern Investment Group, Great American Opportunities, Tasty Selections, Thinking Ahead Executive Search, ThirdHome, Southwestern Publishing Group, Southwestern Travel, and SW Tax Services) As 2021 continues in its uncertain glory, we know that decent, hardworking people around the world will continue to be caught up in MLM schemes. And it’s up to each of us as individuals to be as informed and discerning as we can, to prevent these companies from preying on that one stubborn, human trait we all share: hope. Opportunities for small businesses, such as affiliate marketing, are rather prevalent. Many renowned brands allow you to join as an affiliate. Every sale an affiliate marketer generates for the brand results in a commission. Some companies, like Amazon, give affiliates a small cut of sales for each item they refer. Other companies, like Shopify, offer affiliates up to $58 for each customer they bring in. To drive purchases for the brand you’re endorsing, you can develop a blog, post on social media, or run advertising using your affiliate link.
    Thankfully, marketing video production services can help you build your brand with high volumes of quality video content produced at speed.  Brand videography is an incredibly powerful tool for increasing visibility and engagement with a business or organization’s target audience. Video allows businesses to tell their story in a way that resonates with viewers in an emotional way, while also providing useful information about the organization’s products or services. Additionally, video is becoming increasingly pervasive across all forms of digital media, so having well-crafted brand video content is essential for staying competitive in today’s digital landscape. Building brand awareness and promoting your products through video and content marketing campaigns is one of the most rewarding forms of digital media promotion there is.   We specialize in retail, products and online sales videos.

  8. It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this outstanding blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!

  9. Hey very cool blog!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I am happy to find so many useful information here in the post, we need develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

  10. The most talked about weight loss product is finally here! FitSpresso is a powerful supplement that supports healthy weight loss the natural way. Clinically studied ingredients work synergistically to support healthy fat burning, increase metabolism and maintain long lasting weight loss.

  11. ラブドール 正規の本物のwmdollを販売する販売者は数社ありますが、そのほとんどは偽物であるため、リスクは非常に高くなります。これらの偽のwmdollは、合法的な企業から盗まれたデザインを使用して作成でき、品質管理や安全対策が講じられていない無認可の工場で製造されています。

  12. Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem with your website in internet explorer, would test this… IE still is the market leader and a big portion of people will miss your wonderful writing because of this problem.

  13. Welcome to our website, your pm online nave after African sports, music, and fame updates. We swaddle the whole kit from heady sports events like the Africa Cup of Nations to the latest trends in Afrobeats and usual music. Probe exclusive interviews and features on prominent personalities making waves across the continent and beyond.

    At our website, we lend timely and winsome soothe that celebrates the heterogeneity and vibrancy of African culture. Whether you’re a sports promoter, music lover, or deviant yon Africa’s influential figures, ally our community and stay connected an eye to regular highlights and in-depth stories showcasing the in the most suitable way of African aptitude and creativity

    Befall our website today and dig up the dynamic world of African sports, music, and distinguished personalities. Involve yourself in the richness of Africa’s cultural episode with us!

  14. It’s perfect time to make some plans for the longer term and it is time to be happy. I’ve learn this submit and if I could I want to suggest you few fascinating issues or tips. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *