Catch-up: St Andrews for Syria Panel Discussion

Missed the St Andrews for Syria discussion on Friday night? Don’t worry, The Stand’s got all the details here…

Last Friday night, students and staff streamed into the Buchanan Lecture Theatre. After hours, this was not an academic event – rather, the brainchild of Emily Miller and Ellie Fields: St Andrews for Syria. Comprising of four talks followed by a panel discussion, this event was put on to raise awareness of the situation in Syria, particularly Aleppo, as well as the international responses, both in the media and to the resulting, so-called, ‘refugee crisis’.

After viewing a looped video of destroyed buildings as we entered, Ellie and Emily started off the evening with an overview of how they became interested in the issue and what they hoped to achieve throughout the evening. Professor Raymond Hinnebusch, of the St Andrew’s IR department followed. Though he was not a speaker of the evening, as something of an expert in Middle Eastern politics, he introduced each of the speakers and also ran the panel discussion later on. A welcome message and a thank you to Ellie and Emily was preceded by the first talk.

Dr Idrees Ahmad, author of The Road to Iraq: The Making of a Neoconservative War and lecturer at the University of Stirling, spoke first. He discussed how information is manipulated in the media; how western presentations of the Syrian conflict rarely show the total truth of the situation. An example he named was Robert Fisk, a well-known journalist, who has been ‘embedded’ in Syria for the last few years. Though Fisk has a history of criticising the dangers of embedding, Ahmad presented us with evidence that Fisk himself had fallen prey to these dangers: a distinct loss of objectivity seemed to be the main aspect. Ahmad also spoke of the larger western media, citing (mainly European) reactions to the incoming refugees. Statistics of the percentage that were still at home or internally-displaced, the percentage in places such as Turkey and Lebanon, compared to the percentage that are now in Europe truly drove his message home. He sat down to thunderous applause, and we moved onto the second speaker.


Next was Dr Ayman Al-Yassini, who works in refugee determination in Canada. In his own words, it is difficult work because he is “impacting the lives of individuals”, rather than the statistics refugees are so often seen as. Though his presentation did not speak much of the situation in Syria, he explained much about Canada’s relationship with Syrian refugees. Aylan Kurdi put the topic of refugees onto the agenda of the 2015 Canadian elections, and it was the Liberal party which committed to the entry of 25,000 over the following six months, which eventually won (as opposed to the Conservatives, who focused on fighting Daesh/ISIS and would only allow 15,000 refugees to enter Canada over five years). Al-Yassini discussed the complicated process involved in putting this policy into action, and how it is even ongoing now, as the refugees adjust to life in Canada. Similarly, he compared the merits and downfalls of private sponsors of refugees, a system popular in Canada and open to almost anybody, and government-sponsored intake. To end, he reminded us all that while Syrian refugees do matter, there are a great many other nationalities which need our help and should not be forgotten about.

The next speaker was Dr Jasmine Gani, a lecturer in International Relations here at St Andrews. Her presentation was mostly focused on the lives of refugees. She began with stories of individuals; who they were, how they came to leave Syria, and what their lives were like afterwards. She then moved on to discuss Europe’s attitudes towards refugees. Her main focus was on the humanity of refugees, and the ‘statistics, not people’ approach taken by many governments. She condemned the way they closed their borders to children for ‘security’ reasons, how refugee camps lacked many basic necessities of life, how families were split up and no effort was made by authorities to combat or prevent this. Dr Gani brought up Western attitudes towards Syrian displaced persons when they were still in the Middle East (sympathy) and the contrast to how we treat them when they want to enter our own countries.

She threw statistics at us, like the 4000 refugees who died crossing the Mediterranean sea just this year, the one-fifth of the population of Lebanon that are refugees, in between discussing the political and cultural shift that is needed in mind-sets to help the situation.  Dr Gani talked of the distressing rise of extreme right-wing political parties such as UKIP and Golden Dawn, the dereliction of human responsibility, and the end of the EU programme Mare Nostrum which only led to more deaths. How can we fix this? She says that we, the public, need to build up the momentum of opinion, forcing politicians to welcome, not just tolerate, refugees, and treat them like “human beings, not refugees”.


Finally, Alastair Gordon-Gibson took the stage. He is a current post-graduate student at St Andrews, and completed his undergraduate here as well, but in between has worked for humanitarian organisations such as Red Cross. “1 to 100 deaths is a tragedy; 100,000 is a statistic” was the unofficial theme of his talk. Academics and policy-makers, he argued, view the refugee crisis and their potential responses in very black-and-white terms. However, there has to be a lack of cynicism, a kernel of humanity, in every person, and these are what we should access when we try to figure out how to respond. There is no media attention to ‘liberated’ areas of Syria, though they also need help; soldiers, too, are ignored victims of this conflict. It is organisations like the UN, as well as local and international NGOs, which do what they can to get aid into Syria, though most of their aid does not reach where it is meant to. It is governmental systems that fail us in moments like these, Gordon-Gibson says, as this is a common tragedy that affects all of us, not just Syrians.

When Gordon-Gibson sat back down, we realised that the talks had continued much longer than expected. This meant that the subsequent panel discussion, facilitated by and Professor Hinnebusch, could only go through three or four questions before the event was up. Topics covered in the discussion included the lost generation of Syrian children who missed out on school due to the conflict, whether or not it was possible to reconcile the various narratives on the topic, and how each speaker felt it would be best to stop the conflict without further worsening it.

As we emerged from the Buchanan, there was a definite air of wow. None of the attendees had really expected for our eyes and minds to be opened in such a way. The events in Syria, and their effects on the wider world, were all of a sudden tangible and so much more 3D than they had been mere hours ago. Yes, it was Friday night spent in a lecture theatre listening to people talk, but a Friday night well-spent. In missing this event, you definitely lost out; hopefully this article has done something to alleviate your FOMO.

Huge thanks and appreciation towards Ellie Fields and Emily Miller for putting on the event, and may none of us ever forget it.



1,539 thoughts on “Catch-up: St Andrews for Syria Panel Discussion

  1. Pingback: 2officially
  2. i need a loan with no credit, i need a direct loan lender. i need a loan of 3000 today need loan now, i need a loan but have bad credit rating, cash advance loans with bad credit borrow money now borrow money now, cash advance title loans, cash advance, cash advance loans, cash advance payday loans bad credit ok. Business have acquired business, designed for companies. i need a loan today get loan online need fast loan.

  3. pharmacie de garde roanne pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui ixelles pharmacie florit pharmacie lafayette metz .
    therapie de couple film acteur parapharmacie leclerc hyeres .
    pharmacie angers patton medicaments synonyme , pharmacie lafayette hotel dieu carpentras .

  4. therapie cognitivo comportementale montpellier pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui lyon pharmacie de garde marseille 2 juin 2020 therapie comportementale et cognitive besancon .
    horaire pharmacie autour de moi faculte pharmacie aix en provence .
    medicaments sciatique pharmacie leclerc hazebrouck , pharmacie beaulieu louviers .

  5. First of all, thank you for your post. totosite Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^

  6. They look exactly like the photo. And it’s they’re sturdy enough to be tossed around on a sabacc table. This is my second purchase from this seller, but definitely not last. The Idiot Array will always beat the Pure Sabacc if two (or more) players have the same hands. If no one has either of those hands, the winner will be the player closest to 23. Now, this isn’t the only thing to know about playing Sabacc because you can also Bomb Out! Gold Sabacc Credit Poker Chips Here are some photos of these cool poker chips: Gold Sabacc Credit Solid Metal -the official Sabacc game set from Galaxies Edge at Walt Disney World. Inside is the full set of cards, instructions and two plastic dice. The Idiot Array will always beat the Pure Sabacc if two (or more) players have the same hands. If no one has either of those hands, the winner will be the player closest to 23. Now, this isn’t the only thing to know about playing Sabacc because you can also Bomb Out!
    Governor Of Poker 3 About Google Play Follow Download Free Games Play Governor Of Poker flash game. Governor Of Poker is a Casino game to play free online. Controls: Use your mouse to play The game features an in-game tutorial that appears when new game elements are introduced. Players can check the in-game tutorial for an overview of the poker rules, and tips and trick. Using the in-game tutorial is optional, and players can opt to skip the instructions. The government has outlawed all poker games! Play Texas Hold’em as you fight to overturn the ban and become the Governor of Poker! Prove to the minister of the Texas gambling committee that poker is all about skill and get him to make the game legal again in Governor of Poker 2. Travel to different cities and play poker against different characters in your quest to be the best!

  7. Anna Berezina is a eminent inventor and keynoter in the deal with of psychology. With a family in clinical luny and voluminous research circumstance, Anna has dedicated her calling to armistice sensitive behavior and daft health: By virtue of her achievement, she has made impressive contributions to the battleground and has appropriate for a respected thought leader.

    Anna’s judgement spans several areas of thinking, including cognitive psychology, unmistakable looney, and zealous intelligence. Her voluminous knowledge in these domains allows her to produce valuable insights and strategies as individuals seeking personal proliferation and well-being.

    As an originator, Anna has written disparate controlling books that bear garnered widespread recognition and praise. Her books provide practical par‘nesis and evidence-based approaches to forbear individuals lead fulfilling lives and cultivate resilient mindsets. Away combining her clinical judgement with her passion suited for portion others, Anna’s writings have resonated with readers for everyone the world.

  8. Anna Berezina is a highly talented and famend artist, known for her unique and charming artworks that by no means fail to leave an enduring impression. Her paintings fantastically showcase mesmerizing landscapes and vibrant nature scenes, transporting viewers to enchanting worlds filled with awe and surprise.

    What units – Anna Berezina aside is her exceptional attention to detail and her remarkable mastery of color. Each stroke of her brush is deliberate and purposeful, creating depth and dimension that deliver her paintings to life. Her meticulous approach to capturing the essence of her topics allows her to create truly breathtaking artworks.

    Anna finds inspiration in her travels and the good thing about the natural world. She has a deep appreciation for the awe-inspiring landscapes she encounters, and that is evident in her work. Whether it’s a serene beach at sunset, a majestic mountain vary, or a peaceable forest full of vibrant foliage, Anna has a remarkable capacity to seize the essence and spirit of those locations.

    With a novel artistic style that combines components of realism and impressionism, Anna’s work is a visible feast for the eyes. Her paintings are a harmonious mix of precise particulars and gentle, dreamlike brushstrokes. This fusion creates a captivating visible expertise that transports viewers right into a world of tranquility and wonder.

    Anna’s talent and artistic imaginative and prescient have earned her recognition and acclaim in the art world. Her work has been exhibited in prestigious galleries around the globe, attracting the attention of artwork lovers and collectors alike. Each of her pieces has a means of resonating with viewers on a deeply personal stage, evoking feelings and sparking a way of reference to the pure world.

    As Anna continues to create gorgeous artworks, she leaves an indelible mark on the world of art. Her capability to capture the beauty and essence of nature is actually remarkable, and her paintings serve as a testament to her artistic prowess and unwavering ardour for her craft. Anna Berezina is an artist whose work will proceed to captivate and inspire for years to come back..